| 2011 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Paige Brockington | Spelman College | May |
| Elizabeth Brown | Hampton | Spyropoulos |
| Stephanie Cabrera | Florida International | Baatz |
| Joseph Coz | College of Charleston | Guillette |
| Angela Dapremont | College of Charleston | Greenfield |
| Mary DeVita | Chaminade University of Honolulu | Fulton |
| Jessica Duke | The University of Alabama | Bearden |
| Virginia Fleer | Northwest Missouri State University | Plante |
| Vincent Lazor | University of Deleware | Bearden |
| Teresa Long | University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill | Moeller |
| Michael Mai | College of Charleston | Kindy |
| Wilmelie Marrero | University of Puerto Rico - Humacao | Sotka |
| Zoe Odonoghue | University of South Carolina | Woodley |
| Scott Riley | Virginia Tech | Lovelace |
| Chantel Y. Simpson | North Carolina A & T | Lovelace |
| Aposia Singleton | Morris College | Woodley |
| Tiera Smalls | Queens University of Charlotte | Lovelace |
| Portia Thomas | Erskine College | Christopher |
| Elizabeth Underwood | Davidson College | Guillette |
| Rayona Wise | Miami University of Ohio | K. Burnett / L.Burnett |
| 2010 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Andrew Morrison | Savannah State University | Van Dolah |
| Aurora Baker | Queens University | Morton |
| Destiny Pegram | North Texas | Ditullio |
| Jonathan Nye | UC Santa Cruz | Lovelace |
| Jonathan Williams | University of Mary Washington | Kucklick |
| Lauren Daniels | Savannah State University | Plante/Greenfield |
| Sarah Newton | University of Arkansas, Pine Bluff | Bearden |
| 2009 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Jacob Gantz | Franklin & Marshall College | Sotka |
| Jonathan Jefferies | North Carolina A & T | Bearden |
| Jace Jensen | University of Utah | Bearden |
| Robin Garcia | University of Miami | K. Burnett |
| Val Kuchar | College of Charleston | Plante |
| Chisom Ezenkwe | Clemson University | Wargovich |
| Ruth Tilus | Savannah State University | Baatz |
| Kevin Trappio | Savannah State University | Baatz |
| Nikole Flemming | University of Virgin Islands | Kindy |
| Jordan Allen | Savannah State University | Fulton |
| 2008 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Peter Satin | Vassar College | Galloway |
| Jeffery Slosarczyk | University of Wisconsin | Warr |
| Melanie Campos | Queens University - Charlotte | Morris |
| Samuel Bearden | Vanderbuilt University | Morris |
| Madeline Zaehringer | Midwestern State | Kilpatrick |
| Alex Meyers | Tennessee Tech | Bearden |
| Amanda Waters | University of Oklahoma | Moeller |
| Brittany Wright | Eckerd College | Moeller |
| Britta Voss | University of Washington | Moeller |
| Annie Kwon | Emory University | Baatz |
| Katie Hilleke | Academic Magnet HS | Sotka |
| Alaina Varr | College of Charleston | Sotka |
| Susan Herron | University of South Carolina | Morton |
| Michelle Kelly | University of Arizona | Morton |
| Shannon Wright | College of Charleston | Burnett |
| Amanda Kinney | College of Charleston | Plante |
| Emily Frank | University of Akron | Plante |
| Loren Danese | College of Charleston | DeLorenzo |
| 2007 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Greg Matthews | Indiana Wesleyan University | Morris |
| Reney Henderson Jr. | Howard University | Morris |
| Scottie Mobley | College of Charleston | Galloway |
| Venetia Lyles | SC State University | Morris |
| Sandi Brown | Paine College | Warr |
| 2006 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Hannah Scarborough | Agnes Scott College | Fair |
| Thomas Milar | College of Charleston | Burnett |
| Jennifer Delaney | Rippon College | Morris |
| Sara Dunaway | Anderson University | Woodley |
| 2005 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Charles Kolo Rathburn | Chaminade University of Honolulu | Burnett |
| Ashley Arana | Amherst University | Gross |
| Geoffrey Horwitz | Trinity University | Woodley |
| Emily Long | College of Charleston | Morris |
| Phillip Chisholm | College of Charleston | Becker |
| 2004 | Home Institution | Mentor |
| Tamara Butler | Xavier University of Louisiana | Gross |
| Dan Bakko | Concordia College | Morris |
| Katrina Aleksa | Arizona State University | Kucklick |
| Heather Nees | Muskingum College | Plante |
| Sharon Dayse | SC State University | Morris |
| Stephanie Martin | Tuskegee University | Peden-Adams |
| Sally Upton | Albertson College of Idaho | Becker |
| 2003 | Home Instituition | Mentor |
| Kizee Etienne | Mercer University | Gross |
| Jacqueline Smith | Clemson University | Lacy/Fulton |
| Hugo Tapia | University of Texas El Paso | Morris |
| Elizabeth Hambleton | Williams College | Morris |
| Chris Tanner | The College of New Jersey | Burnett |
| Ryan Templeton | Auburn University | Kucklick |